Electric vs Gas Hot Water System

Choosing the right hot water system is an important decision for any household. Two of the most common options are electric and gas hot water systems. Each type has its advantages and considerations. Comparing electric vs gas hot water systems can help you make an informed decision that best fits your household’s needs and budget.

What is a Gas Hot Water System?

A gas hot water system uses natural gas to heat water, either through a storage tank or an on-demand unit. Many Melbourne homes rely on gas systems because they are reliable and generally more cost-effective to run, especially in areas where gas prices are lower than electricity. Gas systems are designed to deliver consistent hot water and can be a great fit for households with regular water usage patterns.

Types of Gas Hot Water Systems:

Understanding the different types of gas hot water systems can make it easier to choose one that suits your household needs. Each type works differently, so it’s worth looking at how they operate and what they offer.

1. Gas Storage Systems

These systems store hot water in an insulated tank. When you turn on the tap, hot water is ready to use. They’re ideal for families or households where multiple people may need hot water simultaneously. Because the tank maintains a constant temperature, water is available even during periods of high demand.  

2. Instantaneous Gas Systems:

Instantaneous gas systems heat water only when you need it. There’s no storage tank, so they take up less space. These systems are energy-efficient because they don’t maintain hot water around the clock. They’re a smart choice for smaller homes or those looking to reduce standby energy use, while still ensuring a reliable supply of hot water.

Pros of Gas Hot Water Systems

Gas hot water systems offer several practical benefits that make them a popular choice for many Australian homes.

• Instant Hot Water: Gas systems heat water quickly, delivering hot water almost immediately when you turn on the tap. This is especially useful during busy mornings or when hot water is needed frequently throughout the day.
• Lower Running Costs: In areas where natural gas is affordable, gas hot water systems can be more cost-effective to run compared to electric systems. Over time, this can lead to noticeable savings on energy bills.
• Works During Power Outages: One of the key advantages of gas systems is their ability to function even when the electricity is out. This makes them a reliable option, especially in areas where power interruptions are common.
• Suitable for Large Households: Gas systems are well-suited for homes with higher hot water demands. They can provide a consistent supply of hot water, even when multiple taps or showers are in use at the same time.
• Fast Heat Recovery: Gas hot water units generally reheat water faster than electric systems. This is ideal for households where hot water is used in quick succession, such as back-to-back showers.

Cons of Gas Hot Water Systems

While gas systems offer numerous benefits, there are also several key considerations to keep in mind before making a choice.

• Higher Upfront Cost: Gas hot water systems often have a higher initial cost, especially if you’re switching from electric and need to install a gas line or additional infrastructure.
• Requires a Gas Connection: To install a gas system, your home must already have a gas connection. If not, setting one up can increase installation time and cost.
  Space and Ventilation: Gas systems may require extra space for safe installation. Proper ventilation is also necessary to safely discharge combustion gases, especially in indoor settings.
• Professional Installation Required: For safety and compliance with regulations, gas hot water systems must be installed by a licensed professional. This ensures that the system works efficiently and meets all safety standards.

What is an Electric Hot Water System?

Electric hot water systems heat water using electric heating elements, making them a straightforward option for many homes. They are especially useful in areas without access to natural gas and are commonly available in both storage and instantaneous models.

These systems are generally easier to install and maintain. They can be placed in various parts of the home, offering flexibility for different layouts. Although they may be more expensive to operate in areas with high electricity rates, pairing them with solar power can significantly reduce long-term energy costs.

Types of Electric Hot Water System

Electric hot water systems are a popular choice for many homes because they are flexible, easy to install, and can work well in places where gas isn’t available. Let’s take a closer look at the main types:

1. Electric Storage Systems

Electric storage systems are one of the most common types used in Australian homes. They heat water using electric elements and store it in an insulated tank for later use. These systems come in various sizes, making it easier to choose one that fits your household’s daily water usage. They’re straightforward to install and work well for homes that need hot water throughout the day.

2. Instantaneous Electric Systems

Also known as continuous flow systems, these units heat water only when it’s needed. Because there’s no storage tank, they take up less space and are a good option for smaller homes, apartments, or areas where water demand is limited. They provide a steady supply of hot water but may be more suitable for homes with lower overall usage.

3. Electric Heat Pump Systems

Heat pump systems are a more energy-efficient alternative to traditional electric heaters. They use electricity to draw heat from the surrounding air and transfer it to the water. In Melbourne’s climate, they work effectively year-round and can significantly reduce electricity consumption. These systems are also eligible for government rebates, making them a smart long-term investment for those looking to reduce energy costs.

Pros of Electric Hot Water Systems

Electric hot water systems remain a popular choice for many households due to their flexibility and ease of use. Here are some of the key benefits:

• Lower Upfront Cost: Electric systems generally have a lower purchase price and installation cost compared to gas systems. This makes them a good entry-level option, especially for new homeowners or smaller households looking for a reliable solution without a large initial investment.
• Easy to Install: Installing an electric hot water system is usually simple, especially in homes that already have the necessary wiring. They don’t require ventilation or gas connections, making them ideal for apartments, townhouses, and smaller properties where space or access may be limited.
• Solar Power Integration: Electric systems work well with solar energy. When paired with rooftop solar panels, they can run using solar-generated electricity during the day. This can reduce reliance on the grid and significantly lower energy bills.
• Flexible Applications: These systems are versatile and can be installed in a variety of home types and layouts. Whether it’s a single bathroom apartment or a multi-storey townhouse, there’s usually an electric unit that fits.
• Off-peak Electricity Use: Many electric hot water systems can be set to operate during off-peak hours, when electricity rates are lower. This helps reduce running costs and makes them more energy-efficient over time.

 

Cons of Electric Hot Water Systems

While electric hot water systems are convenient and easy to install, they may not be the best fit for every home. Like any appliance, they have limitations, including:

• Higher Running Costs (Without Solar): If your home doesn’t use solar panels or off-peak rates, electricity costs can be higher compared to gas-powered systems. This can increase your energy bills over time, especially in households with high hot water usage.Dependence on Electricity: These systems rely entirely on the power supply. In the event of a power outage, there may be no access to hot water until electricity is restored.
• Slower Heating Times: Electric systems generally take longer to heat water compared to gas options. This may not be ideal in homes where hot water is needed quickly or in high volumes.
• May Need Electrical Upgrades: Larger electric systems, particularly high-capacity models, may require electrical upgrades to ensure they operate safely and efficiently. This can increase installation costs if your current setup isn’t suitable.

Gas Hot Water vs Electric Hot Water: Direct Comparison

Choosing between a gas and electric hot water system involves more than just picking a brand or price point. Each system has its own strengths, and the right option will depend on your home’s setup, energy goals, and daily water needs. Here’s a simple side-by-side gas hot water vs electric hot water comparison:

Feature	Gas Hot Water System	Electric Hot Water System
Upfront Cost	Moderate to high, including installation of gas lines and ventilation	Generally lower to moderate, with simpler installation
Running Cost	Usually lower because natural gas tends to be cheaper than electricity	Typically, higher unless paired with solar energy to offset costs
Heating Speed	Heats water quickly, beneficial during periods of high usage	Slower heating time, though adequate for smaller households
Environmental Impact	Moderate to high, but improved when combined with solar gas systems	Varies depending on electricity source; can be very clean when powered by renewables
Installation Complexity	Requires access to a gas supply and proper venting, which adds complexity	Easier installation, often plug-and-play, suitable for many home types
Best Suited For	Larger families or homes with high hot water demands	Smaller households, apartments, or homes with solar setups

Key Factors for Choosing Your Water Heating System

Selecting the right water heating system depends on several practical considerations. Taking time to weigh these points can help you avoid unnecessary expenses and ensure reliable hot water every day.

Household Size and Water Usage

The number of people in your home and how often hot water is used will play a big role in your decision. Larger families or homes with high water demand may benefit more from a gas system due to its faster heating and better recovery rate. For smaller homes or households with lower demand, an electric system might be sufficient and cost-effective.

Energy Efficiency and Sustainability Goals

If reducing energy consumption or switching to more sustainable options is a priority, consider pairing an electric system with solar panels. This combination can significantly lower electricity bills and environmental impact over time.

Upfront vs Long-term Costs

Gas systems can sometimes have a higher initial installation cost due to additional fittings or ventilation requirements. However, they may cost less to run over time, especially for larger households. Electric systems may cost less to install, but could lead to higher running costs unless paired with solar.

Availability of a Gas Connection

If your home already has a gas line, a gas water heater might be easier to install. However, if no gas connection is available, installing one can add to the cost. In that case, electric systems offer a more straightforward option.

Space for Installation:

Storage systems require sufficient space for the tank. Gas systems may also need additional room for proper ventilation. If your space is limited, an electric instantaneous system might be a better choice.

The Solar Integration Advantage

If you’re exploring ways to make your home more energy-efficient, integrating your electric hot water system with solar panels is a smart and practical solution. Using solar energy to power your electric hot water system can reduce your reliance on the electricity grid. Here are some key advantages of combining solar with your hot water setup:

1. Reduced Operating Costs: By using solar energy, your system can preheat the water during daylight hours using free, renewable power. This reduces the amount of electricity drawn from the grid, leading to noticeable savings on operating costs.
2. Environmental Impact: Solar-powered electric systems reduce your household’s carbon footprint. This is a simple way to make your home more environmentally friendly without compromising on daily comfort.
3. Government Incentives: In Victoria and other parts of Australia, eligible households can access government rebates and solar incentives. These may include rebates for solar hot water systems and feed-in tariffs for excess energy sent back to the grid.
4. Energy Independence: Using solar power allows homeowners to reduce dependence on the electricity grid by generating their own energy. You’ll be less impacted by fluctuating electricity prices and gain better control over your energy usage and ongoing costs.

Why Choose VCM Plumbing for Your Water Heating Systems

With over two decades of experience, VCM Plumbing is a trusted provider of hot water system services across Melbourne. Here’s why many homeowners rely on us:

1. Servicing Across Melbourne
2. Transparent Pricing
3. 20+ Years of Experience
4. Licensed Professionals
5. Quality Assurance
6. Customer-focused Approach

If you’re unsure which gas, electric, or solar hot water system is right for your home, VCM Plumbing can help you make an informed choice. To get started, email us at info@vcmplumbing.com.au or call us on 0438 073 355. You’ll receive friendly support, professional guidance, and a clear, no-obligation quote tailored to your needs.

FAQs